An Ignorant Age Has Many Books

From “Books Multiplied by Useless Compilations” in The Idler.
Text from the 1761 compilation of Johnson's Idler essays, available from the Internet Archive.

One of the peculiarities which distinguish the present age, is the multiplication of books. Every day brings new advertisements of literary undertakings, and we are flattered with repeated promises of growing wise on easier terms than our progenitors.

How much either happiness or knowledge is advanced by this multitude of Authors, it is not very easy to decide.

He that teaches us any thing which we knew not before, is undoubtedly to be reverenced as a Master. He that conveys knowledge by more pleasing ways, may very properly be loved as a Benefactor; and he that supplies life with innocent amusement, will be certainly caressed as a pleasing companion.

But few of those who fill the world with books, have any pretensions to the hope either of pleasing or instructing. They have often no other task than to lay two books before them, out of which they compile a third, without any new materials of their own, and with very little application of judgement to those which former Authors have supplied.

That all compilations are useless I do not assert. Particles of Science are often very widely scattered. Writers of extensive comprehension have incidental remarks upon topics very remote from the principal subject, which are often more valuable than formal treatises, and which yet are not known because they are not promised in the title. He that collects those under proper heads is very laudably employed, for tho’ he exerts no great abilities in the work, he facilitates the progress of others, and by making that easy of attainment which is already written, may give some mind, more vigorous or more adventurous than his own, leisure for new thoughts and original designs.

But the collections poured lately from the press have been seldom made at any great expense of time or inquiry, and therefore only serve to distract choice without supplying any real want.

It is observed that a corrupt Society has many laws; and I know not whether it is not equally true, that an ignorant Age has many Books. When the treasures of ancient knowledge lye unexamined, and original Authors are neglected and forgotten, Compilers and Plagiaries are encouraged, who give us again what we had before, and grow great by setting before us what our own sloth had hidden from our view.

Yet are not even these Writers to be indiscriminately censured and rejected. Truth like Beauty varies its fashions, and is best recommended by different dresses to different minds; and he that recalls the attention of mankind to any part of learning which time has left behind it, may be truly said to advance the literature of his own age. As the manners of nations vary, new topicks of persuasion become necessary, and new combinations of imagery are produced; and he that can accommodate himself to the reigning taste, may always have readers who perhaps would not have looked upon better performances.

To exact of every man who writes that he should say something new, would be to reduce Authors to a small number; to oblige the most fertile Genius to say only what is new, would be to contract his volumes to a few pages. Yet, surely, there ought to be some bounds to repetition; libraries ought no more to be heaped forever with the same thoughts differently expressed, than with the same books differently decorated.

The good or evil which these secondary Writers produce is seldom of any long duration. As they owe their existence to change of fashion, they commonly disappear when a new fashion becomes prevalent. The Authors that in any nation last from age to age are few, because there are very few that have any other claim to notice than that they catch hold on present curiosity, and gratify some accidental desire, or produce some temporary conveniency.

But however the Writers of the Day may despair of future Fame, they ought at least to forbear any present mischief. Though they cannot arrive at eminent heights of excellence, they might keep themselves harmless. They might take care to inform themselves before they attempt to inform others, and exert the little influence which they have for honest purposes.

But such is the present state of our literature, that the ancient Sage, who thought a great Book a great Evil, would now think the multitude of Books a multitude of Evils. He would consider a bulky Writer who engrossed a year, and a swarm of Pamphleteers who stole each an hour, as equal wasters of human life, and would make no other difference between them, than between a Beast of Prey, and a Flight of Locusts.

Related Selections

Last modified: 18 January, 13:55, MMXIII

Originally posted: 06 September, 10:19, MMXII